Wishful Thinking in Strategic Environments
نویسندگان
چکیده
Towards developing a theory of systematic biases about strategies, I analyze strategic implications of a particular bias: wishful thinking about the strategies. Considering canonical state spaces for strategic uncertainty, I identify a player as a wishful thinker at a state if she hopes to enjoy the highest payoff that is consistent with her information about the others’ strategies at that state. I develop a straightforward elimination process that characterizes the strategy profiles that are consistent with wishful thinking, mutual knowledge of wishful thinking, and so on. Every pure-strategy Nash equilibrium is consistent with common knowledge of wishful thinking. For generic two-person games, I further show that the pure Nash equilibrium strategies are the only strategies that are consistent with common knowledge of wishful thinking, providing an unusual epistemic characterization for equilibrium strategies. I also investigate the strategic implications of rationality and ex-post optimism, the situation in which a player’s expected payoff weakly exceeds her actual payoff. I show that these strategic implications are generically identical to those of wishful thinking whenever each player’s payoff is monotone in others’ strategies. Date: July, 2004. I thank Daron Acemoglu, Haluk Ergin, Casey Rothschild, Marzena Rostek and Jonathan Weinstein for detailed comments. 1
منابع مشابه
Wishful thinking in effective decision making
Creating agents that act reasonably in uncertain environments is a primary goal of agent-based research. In this work we explore the theory that wishful thinking can be an effective strategy in uncertain and competitive decision scenarios. Specifically, we present the constraints necessary for wishful thinking to outperform Expected Utility Maximization and take instances of popular games from ...
متن کاملDevelopment of wishful thinking in 7 to 14 year-old Iranian children and adolescences
Several studies have investigated wishful thinking or desirability bias in children and adults, while no research has been conducted on the evolution of wishful thinking in childhood and adolescence. The present research aims to investigate the evolution of wishful thinking in Iranian children and adolescents aged 7-14. This study is an evolutional one with a cross- sectional method. The statis...
متن کاملNOVASTOR WHITE PAPER Wishful Thinking vs. Reality in Regards to Virtual Backup and Restore Environments
متن کامل
A Framework for Understanding Wishful Thinking
While the science and values literature has seen recurrent concerns about wishful thinking, there have been few efforts to characterize this phenomenon. Based on a review of varieties of wishful thinking involved in climate skepticism, we argue that instances of wishful thinking can be fruitfully characterized in terms of the mechanisms that generate them and the problems associated with them. ...
متن کاملA Bounded Rationality Account of Wishful Thinking
People tend towards wishful thinking, in which they overestimate the probability of favorable outcomes and underestimate the probability of unfavorable outcomes. Many explanations for this phenomenon focus on its irrationality. We explore whether wishful thinking could actually help people make better decisions given that they have limited cognitive resources. We consider a situation in which m...
متن کامل